Islam Question and Answer - He told the students to pay money towards classroom renovations and he gives them grades accordingly

Mon 6/4/1431 - 22/3/2010

» What are lamam (“small faults”)? And what is the ruling on a disobedient Muslim who repeatedly commits them?.

» It is not permissible to say that you were present at a lecture from which you were absent.

» His boss gave him the job of following up on some technical drawings, and he managed to save some money on that.

» Should a man listen to his wife’s suggestions and consult her about matters?.

» Is there more reward if the congregation is greater?.

» He has a partnership in a commercial venture on the basis that every time they buy a dozen with his money, he will have ten riyals.

» How children can honour their parents.

» He got to know a girl through the internet and he wants to marry her but her father is refusing.

» The earliest time for Jumu‘ah prayer.

» Taking a sample of clothing from a store and making something similar with the intention of selling it.

40234

Principles of Fiqh » Jurisprudence and Islamic Rulings » Transactions » Employment for a Salary » Ruling on jobs
Principles of Fiqh » Jurisprudence and Islamic Rulings » Transactions » Business and Financial Transactions » Taxes
Principles of Fiqh » Jurisprudence and Islamic Rulings » Transactions » Forbidden Kinds of Wealth

He told the students to pay money towards classroom renovations and he gives them grades accordingly

The teacher asked us to pay 30 riyals before the exam for renovating the classroom, and he gave extra marks for participation or extra marks in the exam if the participation mark was already complete… and he claimed that this is permissible because the extra marks were not on the exam paper, rather it was in the final total of the marks and the opportunity was available to all students. It was to be paid before the exam and whoever was not able to pay that money could have had the amount reduced and if he was not able to pay at all, he could have been let off, so he could still have the same advantage as the other students had who did pay. Is what he did correct? Please give a detailed reply, quoting evidence.

Praise be to Allaah.

The teacher does not have the right to take anything from the students, even if that this for the purpose of renovating the classroom, because that is not the responsibility of the students; rather it is the responsibility of the school. This money in many ways is similar to the haraam maks (customs levy or purchase tax) – see question no. 39461 concerning the prohibition of the maks.

Marks for participation are only given to students for their efforts and hard work in their studies, not for giving money to the teacher! The same applies to grades in the test, they should be based on what the student has written on his test paper, and have nothing to do with renovation or adornment of the classroom.

If the teacher gives marks to students in return for them giving him money, this goes against the education system and is also wronging people with regard to their wealth, and exposing the poorer students to embarrassment when they have to tell him that they cannot pay all or some of the money.

The teacher has to fear Allaah and give each student the grades that he deserves according to the education system that is in place. He should not ask the students for money, no matter how little.

The teacher should encourage the students to donate money for repairs to the classroom, or for any other charitable cause. That comes under the heading of cooperating in righteousness and piety. It also makes the students get used to spending money on charitable causes. But that should have nothing to do with the grades that the students get.

And Allaah knows best.

Islam Q&A