Praise be to Allaah.
Firstly:
Immunisation – which is also called protection and
vaccination – makes the body of the one who is immunised produce substances
known as antibodies; their function is to fight disease. They do not, in
principle, cause disease to the one who is immunised. What happens of
side-effects as a result of being immunised cannot be compared to the future
benefits, in sha Allah.
In al-Mawsoo‘ah al-‘Arabiyyah al-‘Aalamiyyah it says:
Protection or active immunisation is another word for vaccination. The
vaccine contains a substance that can strengthen the immunity of the body
and enable it to produce antibodies to a specific contagious disease. These
antibodies protect the individual if he catches the live agent that causes
the disease. The vaccine contains a strong substance that is enough to
stimulate production of antibodies but it is not strong enough to cause the
actual disease. Most vaccines contain the bacteria that causes the disease
or dead viruses; some others contain living pathogens but they are in a
weakened state that cannot cause the disease. These vaccines contain toxins
that are secreted by the pathogens that cause the disease and these toxins
are treated chemically so that they give immunity without causing disease.
Secondly:
The ruling on immunisation depends on the ruling on the
substance used in it and the effects it has. They are of different types:
-1-
The first type is substances that are basically permissible
to use and have beneficial effects.
There is no doubt that these are permissible; in fact they
are among the great blessings that Allah, may He be exalted, has bestowed
upon His creation. This medical achievement has put an end to the spread of
many epidemics.
Shaykh Sa‘d ibn Naasir al-Shathri (may Allah preserve him)
said:
Among issues having to do with epidemics and contagious
diseases is the ruling on vaccinations that are given in order to protect
against these diseases. We say: vaccinations are of two types:
(i)
Vaccinations the effects of
which are known from experience to give protection against this disease by
Allah’s leave. The ruling on these is that they come under the same ruling
as medical treatment, as they are a type of medical treatment. That is
because they are included in the words of the Prophet (blessings and peace
of Allah be upon him): “Seek medical treatment.” So they come under the same
rulings as medical treatment. Some fuqaha’ had a problem with the idea of
vaccinations and said: The vaccination is a reduced level of sickness that
is transferred to the body so that the body will be able to fight the real
sickness (so that the body gets used to resisting sickness). They said: How
can we allow introducing sickness into the body? But the more correct view
is that there is nothing wrong with doing that; rather it is a righteous act
because the introduction of harm in this case does not result in further
harm; rather it serves a purpose which is to protect the one who receives
this vaccination from severe illness. This indicates that there is nothing
wrong with receiving this vaccination.
End quote from a lecture entitled
Ahkaam Fiqhiyyah tata‘allaq bil Awbi’ah
http://www.al-adwa.net/?p=181
See also the words of Shaykh ‘Abd al-‘Azeez ibn Baaz (may
Allah have mercy on him) in the answer to question no.
20276.
Whether this permissible substance is a virus or bacteria or
some other substance, they all come under the heading of that which it is
permissible to consume if it will have a beneficial effect.
See the ruling on treating sickness with toxins and using
toxins in vaccines in the answer to question no.
109424.
-2-
The second type is that which is a substance that it is
permissible to use, but it causes more harm than good to the body or it is
of no benefit at all.
With regard to these vaccinations there is no doubt that it
is not permissible to use them because we have been forbidden to harm
ourselves by consuming harmful food, drink, medicine and so on.
See the answer to question no.
20276.
-3-
The third type is that which is made from a substance that
was originally haraam or impure (najis) but it has been chemically treated
or other substances have been added to it that changed it in name and
quality to a permissible substance, which is what is called istihaalah or
transformation, and it has a beneficial effect.
In al-Mawsoo‘ah al-‘Arabiyyah al-‘Aalamiyyah it says:
Some vaccines are made from parts or secretions of the live
agents that cause the disease and other types of vaccinations are made from
live agents that are similar to those that cause the disease. These agents
give immunity but they do not cause disease. End quote.
It is permissible to have these vaccinations because the
transformation that changed the name and quality of the substance also
changed the ruling, so they became permissible to use.
Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allah have mercy on him)
said:
With regard to smoke from an impure substance or matter, (the
ruling) is based on a principle which is that the impure substance, if it is
transformed and becomes good like other goos substances, it is pure, like
what falls into the saltworks of blood, animals that die naturally (without
being slaughtered properly) and pigs becomes pure salt like the rest of the
salt.
There are two scholarly views concerning this type of
transformation. One view is that it does not become pure, as is the view of
al-Shaafa‘i and is also one of the two views of the madhhab of Maalik; it is
also the well known view of the companions of Ahmad and is one of the two
opinions narrated from him. The other view is that it does become pure. This
is the view of Abu Haneefah and of Maalik according to one of the two
opinions, and it is one of the two opinions narrated from Ahmad.
The view of the literalists and others is that it becomes
pure, and this is the definitive correct view, because these transformed
substances are not referred to in any text of prohibition, whether
explicitly or implicitly. So they are not haraam and there is no reason for
them to be haraam, and there is no justification to suggest that they are
haraam. Rather the texts indicate that they are halaal because they are
pure. They also come under the category that all are agreed is halaal.
End quote from Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa, 21/70, 71
-4-
The fourth category includes every substance that is harmful
or haraam, or the effect of which is not certain or there is a difference of
opinion among doctors and specialists as to whether it is beneficial.
It is not permissible to take these vaccinations because of
the possibility of exposing oneself to death and disease.
Shaykh Sa‘d ibn Naasir al-Shathri (may Allah preserve him)
said:
One of the issues having to do with epidemics and contagious
diseases is the ruling on taking vaccinations that are given to protect
against these diseases. We say that the vaccinations are of two types:
(i)
… Mentioned above.
(ii)
Vaccination against contagious
diseases where there is no certainty of its effect and it is not yet known
from experience, or the doctors differ concerning it and there is nothing to
base one’s judgement on and there was no medical opinion that seems to be
more correct than others. In that case the basic principle is that it should
not be taken and it is not permissible, because there is no certainty that
it will have the effect of protecting against disease, but we are certain
that it is harmful and that it is damaging to physical well-being, and we
cannot be certain that its benefits outweigh its harms. Therefore we
disallow it because we do not allow doing anything unless its benefits
outweigh its harms. If we are not sure about that then the basic principle
is that it is disallowed, i.e., if we are certain that a particular action
is harmful and that the benefit that may result from this action is not
proven, then in this case it is disallowed.
End quote from a lecture entitled
Ahkaam Fiqhiyyah tata‘allaq bil Awbi’ah
http://www.al-adwa.net/?p=181
And Allah knows best.